Skip to main content

Reduce Poverty: Much Neglected

Dilli Raj Khanal

A progressive distributional policy together with the suitable institutional setups and arrangements at the grassroots for ensuring exclusively the access of poor to social and physical infrastructure as well as financial services is also a necessity.
As a part of global event, poverty eradication day was celebrated in Nepal recently with claims that Nepal is one of the best performers in this area. If estimated poverty trends are looked into, there are no grounds to refute such an assertion.
According to official figures, in 20 year’s period poverty has reduced by more than 20 per cent, from 41.8 per cent in 1995/96 to 21.2 per cent in 2015/16. Compared to the average GDP growth rate of 3.7 per cent in that period, the poverty reduction rate was about 3.2 per cent per annum.
The breakdown by different updated poverty estimated periods give an interesting pattern. For instance, the annual poverty reduction rate was sharpest at 3.7 per cent annually during 1995/96 to 2003/2004, surpassing the growth rate.
This was the period when the country was trapped in deeper conflict. The latest poverty estimates further show that the reduction rate was equally high at 3.2 per cent during the period 2012/13 to 2015/16, higher than the growth rate.
Noticeably, this was the period when more than 7 lakhs earthquake affected people were additionally pushed below the poverty line as pointed out officially at that time.
Too much rhetoric or thrust, poverty is still a much neglected area, treated in isolation and tautological way without making it an integral part of our development discourse.
More worryingly, still the official poverty estimates are consumption based which have been termed as obsolete since long.
Though for easiness and data reasons these are used for international comparisons, from a country’s standpoint such an approach overlooks the complex poverty and underdevelopment related factors and thereby misleads the policy discourse.
For instance, if consumption based poverty of 2010/11 is looked into, it is seen that about 60 per cent of the lowest quintile groups having only 24.1 per cent of income consume around 34 per cent of total consumption.
From the income side, more than 40 per cent of the lowest income group earn less than poverty threshold income of NRs 19,261 and hence unlike the consumption based poverty of 25.2 per cent, income based poverty comes out above 40 per cent.
This shows that despite remittances boosting consumption even of lower income groups, the principle contributory factor has been the debt as income and consumption gap reveals. This depicts the threat of worsening of living conditions of such groups.
Such an approach overlooks the widely accepted poverty concept. Poverty is now conceived as deprivation of people from well-being driven by both physiological and social deprivation. Physiological deprivation involves denial of fulfilling basic biological needs, including nutrition, health, education, and shelter.
It also includes lack of access to basic physical infrastructure facilities. Social deprivation includes vulnerability, lack of independence or autonomy, powerlessness, and self-respect.
In societies where deprivation is rooted in various forms of discriminations and exclusions driven by political, economic, social and culturally driven structural factors, poverty must be recognized as a multidimensional phenomenon.
Even the consumption based poverty corroborates that along with rising gap between haves and have not’s, poverty is very high among deprived castes, ethnic groups and areas and regions.
Hence, first of all there is an urgency of embracing the above concept and evolving appropriate methodology to compute the extent of poverty in Nepal as a base.
As an extension of computing human development indices, there are attempts globally to introduce deprivation led multidimensional approach in poverty estimates. In that three dimensions viz, education, health and standard of living with equal weights are included.
In the later, electricity, sanitation, water, floor, cooling fuel and assets are included. The recent estimates show that the MDPI is in the neighborhood of 44.2 per cent.
Such a method still omits income, productive employment and other social deprivation linked factors. Therefore, there is a need of developing more robust methodology following the above poverty definition to assess the poverty conditions and gauge more realistically the decisive factors perpetuating deprivation.
The development discourse envisaged in the constitution and Sustainable Development Goals set for 2030 underscore such a necessity.
Such a new poverty approach with its multidimensional base will require restructuring of the development discourse backed by redesigning of compatible strategies, policies, programs and intuitional set ups and arrangements in a coherent way.
In place of neo-liberal orthodoxy, transformable approach with topmost focus on structural and institutional reforms for unleashing the productive forces will be required.
Revamping of economic policy discourse preceded by macro policy reform is a must to enhance productive investment and employment led higher growth.
A progressive distributional policy together with the suitable institutional setups and arrangements at the grassroots for ensuring exclusively the access of poor to social and physical infrastructure as well as financial services is also a necessity.
Without political will and sincerity including determination to overhaul existing governance system, such a discourse will be a mirage rather than a reality.
The Himalayan Times November 11, 2016
http://thehimalayantimes.com/opinion/reduced-poverty-much-neglected/

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

PM Dahal to discuss with ex-PMs, China affairs experts before China visit

As Prime Minister Pushpa Kamal Dahal is preparing to pay an official visit to China on March 23, the PM is scheduled to discuss the matter with former Prime Ministers and China affairs experts beforehand. A meeting of former PMs and China affairs experts has been called at PM Dahal's official residence in Baluwatar at 9 am on Thursday in this regard, said PM Dahal's press advisor Gobinda Acharya. PM Dahal's prior discussions with former PMs and China affairs experts aims to take suggestions on bilateral and multilateral meetings. PM Dahal is scheduled to hold with Chinese officials during the visit, said PM's Secretariat. A Cabinet meeting scheduled to take place today evening will finalise issues to be taken up from Nepal side in the Boao Forum for Asia Annual Conference, Acharya informed. PM Dahal is leaving Thursday for China to take part in the annual conference of Boao Forum for Asia to be held in Boao, Hainan province from March 23-26. On the occasion, PM Dahal is…

Elections to oppose regional politics: Chair Oli

CPN (UML) chair and former Prime Minister K P Sharma Oli has said that the upcoming elections will vehemently oppose and respond to the regional politics and forces involved in disharmonizing the social cohesion. Speaking in a program organized to extend thanks to the volunteers, artists and media for their presence and support shown during the party's Mechi-Mahakali Campaign (March 4-18), leader Oli said so. He added that the people will answer those forces by giving a majority seats to his party from upcoming elections.
Leader Oli further shared that the party will launch more effective programme in Province No 2 in near future. He added that the Madhesi morcha showed apolitical behaviors against UML during the campaign being intolerable due to fear of ending their illusion against the constitution and UML if UML launched effective and harmonious programs in Tarai.In another context, chair Oli shared that the attorney general suggested the election commission to touch the party s…

Minister of my health

Biswas BaralThe curious case of Gagan Thapa I don’t know Gagan Thapa well. What I know better is that I want him to continue as my health minister. How many ministers have there been in the post-1990 democratic Nepal who have done something worthwhile for the common folks and not directed all their focus on enriching themselves and their mother parties? Gokarna Bista. Lalbabu Pandit. Janardan Sharma. Narayan Kaji Shrestha. There aren’t many. This is why when we have someone like Gagan Thapa in the cabinet we should ensure that he stays put for at least a few years. 
If you want to know what Thapa has done, you only need to visit Kanti Children’s Hospital at Maharajgunj, which was until recently among our most mismanaged and dirtiest public hospitals—and this was a hospital for children. The doctors, nurses and other staff there were rude, offensive even, to the parents who brought their children there for treatment. Nor did the hospital staffs seem to have a clue about how to deal with …